RogerEye on the Long Term

By: Roger Doughty In: 2009 Annual Conference| Philanthropy

4 May 2009

[Editor’s note: We asked contributors to tell us a question they think philanthropy needs to explore as the Atlanta conference begins. Here’s Roger’s answer.]

Naming just one question that philanthropy “must explore right now” isn’t easy. We’d all have quite a list, I imagine. But I’d choose this. How do we keep our eye on the long-term even as we and those we serve are consumed by economic crisis?

The short-term – likely even the middle-term – is going to be bad. We read about it all the time. It’ll echo throughout the Atlanta conference. Endowments have been clobbered, good nonprofits are reeling, and, most importantly, the people the nonprofits serve are suffering, in trouble, and scared.

Anytime calamity strikes, our impulse is to focus on nothing else. And of course the field must help grantees cope with the unfolding disaster. But it would be a mistake to do so at the cost of neglecting the longer-term future. Philanthropy needs to act now to prepare for it. Here are just two of the ways.

First, we need to get serious about creating new philanthropic capital. Tumbling endowments make it clearer than ever that we simply don’t have–much less grant out–funds commensurate with the giant challenges before us. It’s almost as obvious that we won’t have enough tomorrow or the next day. In other words, we’ve got a supply problem.

The demand isn’t likely to shrink over the next 25-50 years. If philanthropy is to meet even a fraction of that demand, it must grow. Some growth will surely be through tried-and-true means such as new private foundations and community foundations. But those won’t be enough. We have to find new ways.

One example: A handful of foundations are already investing in developing philanthropy among populations as diverse as young entrepreneurs, communities of color, the lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (“LGBT”) community, immigrants, and youth. Most of those investments will only pay off over many years; creating philanthropic capital takes time. But the pay-off will be stunning–if the field invests now.

Second, philanthropy needs to respond less reactively and more comprehensively to the imperatives of deepening diversity and inclusion. Seismic demographic changes shape our times, changes so great that it’s hard to appreciate just how dramatic and rapid they are. Certainly there have been some hopeful recent changes in philanthropy, such as increased diversity at the program officer level and heightened visibility of diversity and inclusion. At the same time, we’ve also seen a defensiveness and resistance that are ultimately counterproductive, and likely to spur the very kind of regulation that few of us would welcome. The future’s barreling down–a very different future from today–and we can’t afford not to move forward more decisively now.

2 Responses to Eye on the Long Term

» Luminosity function Montessori-Based Dementia Programming

May 4th, 2009 at 7:57 pm

[...] Eye on the Long Term - RE:Philanthropy [...]

Jewelle Gomez

May 5th, 2009 at 8:53 pm

I appreciate putting the focus on long term needs of organizations. It is going to be unnerving to see the organizations that don’t make it through the crisis. However we should be thinking larger; thinking about how groups can re-imagine themselves and, more importantly how funders can do things differently than in the past. Getting funders to break out of their traditions is not going to be easy.

Comment Form

Welcome to RE: Philanthropy! In this blog, guest and Council bloggers share ideas and insights on the most pressing issues in philanthropy. If you want to contribute, please contact

The opinions expressed in this blog are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the Council on Foundations.


Josephine Ramirez
R. Christine Hershey
Malika Harrison
Kate Nielsen
Alexis Raymond
Robyn Schein
Diana Doyle
Marilyn Gelber
Margaret Gage
Phil Hall
Kate Schrauth
Ambrose Clancy
Matt Charles
Lisa Richter
Amy Owen
David Matthew
Kaberi Banerjee-Murthy
Mayur Patel and Diana Scearce
Sarita Venkat
Brian Collier
Rockhelle Johnson
Chauncy Lennon
Susan McPherson
Elizabeth Ramirez
Sherry Ristau
Stephen Pratt
Michael Moody
Michelle Byrd
Mindie Reule
Mena Amin
Helen Ishii
David Imbert
Jeff Pickering and Susanne Norgard
Stephanie Hyre
Trabian Shorters
Kathryn Merchant
Rachael Gibson
Jackie Franey
Katherine Jacobs
Diana Sieger
Stephanie de Wolfe
Robert Smith
Mimi Goodwill
Sue Santa
Lyle Matthew Kan
Andrea Jett
Laila Mehta
Marco F. Cocito-Monoc
Aimee Guidera
Sam Stern