In this tough economy, one of the most frequent calls we’re receiving at the National Center for Family Philanthropy is from families re-thinking perpetuity. It’s understandable that when the needs are so great, donors would debate whether the immediate impact their foundations could have outweighs the benefit of staying in the grantmaking business to benefit society for years to come. It’s also a question that is arising more often because some of today’s most visible funders, such Bill and Melinda Gates, have announced their intention to limit the life of their foundations. Yet they are the minority. A  Foundation Center/Council on Foundations study last year found that only 12 percent of family foundations plan to limit their life spans.

Regardless of what a donor family’s decision is about perpetuity, it’s good news that more of them are even raising the question. For many years, perpetuity has been the default position. The donor’s legal advisor who set up the foundation assumed it was forever; alternatives weren’t even discussed. Generations later, the family may be grappling with keeping the foundation going as they grow apart geographically—and sometimes ideologically. Yet the subject remains taboo—sometimes because of reluctance to dishonor the donor’s wishes.

I think it’s healthy for donors and families to discuss perpetuity periodically. Avoiding what might be an uncomfortable conversation misses an opportunity to consider the big picture—the family’s goals for their philanthropy. I hope donor families will make it a New Year’s resolution to put perpetuity on their board agenda, and weigh the pros and cons. If the decision is to commit to perpetuity, you might want to revisit that choice every three to 10 years to insure the commitment stays strong and you are doing what you must to be successful over the years.

Susan Price is vice president at the National Center for Family Philanthropy. Price, along with 20 guests, will blog at the upcoming Family Philanthropy Conference in San Diego, January 31 to February 2. If you’re joining us at the conference, plan to attend the session Leaders Salon: Is Giving in Perpetuity Right for your Family? on Tuesday, February 2 from 10a.m. to 11:30a.m.

2 Responses to Decide to Decide

Lauren Katzowitz Shenfield

January 12th, 2010 at 11:48 am

Addressing – and revisiting — the question of perpetuity is a paramount factor in aligning family and philanthropic goals. When family foundations focus solely on the latter, an elephant stalks the room, and, as we all know, elephants swing their trunks but don’t say much. Communications matter at the foundation table — within families, across branches and up and down the generations. Family foundations who find the subject of perpetuity deeply buried or just “too hot,” should consider engaging a consultant for a facilitated discussion or family retreat.
Lauren Katzowitz Shenfield is Principal and Senior Advisors of Philanthropy Advisors, LLC. She is accredited to administer the National Center for Family Philanthropy’s Pursuit of Excellence Assessment program.

Ellen Israelson

January 25th, 2010 at 11:02 am

Quite true, the decision about perpetuity needs to be part of the ongoing discussion about strategic philanthropy. Families should seek advisors who are familiar with the range of giving vehicles that can be put into place to perpetuate the family legacy, either with or without the foundation. The vehicle should fit the goal and may need to change over time depending on asset level, giving philosophy, family demographics and societal needs. Philanthropists should not confuse perpetuating their vision for society’s improvement and honoring their family’s legacy with continuing a foundation structure.

Comment Form

Welcome to RE: Philanthropy! In this blog, guest and Council bloggers share ideas and insights on the most pressing issues in philanthropy. If you want to contribute, please contact

The opinions expressed in this blog are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the Council on Foundations.


Marie-Frances Rivera
Tina Arnoldi
Ben Francisco Maulbeck
Diana Campoamor
Robert K. Ross
Hillary Nather-Detisch
Jeff Hoffman
Priscilla Enriquez
Emily Jones Rushing
Katie Loovis
Brooke Ramsey
Nelli Garton
Lisa Parker
John F. Rohe
Anne Sekula
Kevin R. Webb
Courtney Spalding-Mayer
Carmen Fields
Adrienne Mansanares
Mark Baldassare
Rajasvini Bhansali
Jeffrey Cufaude
Matt Robertson
Ronn Richard
Dewayne Matthews
John Tyler
Donnell Mersereau
Dawn Plimmer
Mary Phillips
Amy Philips Haller
Michele Frix
Ashley Harper
Thomas Davis
Rick Martinez
George McCully
Nancy Jost
Niki Jagpal
Laurel Lee-Alexander
John Anderson
Sandie Palomo-Gonzalez
Ira Strumwasser, Ph.D.
Zeke Spier
Niamani Mutima
Heather Peeler
Gladys Washington
Mary Vallier-Kaplan
Emmett Carson
Rick Mappin
Novelette Peterkin