GeorgeStevens“The Gathering of the Glum” Has It Wrong on Economic Recovery

By: George Stevens In: 2010 Fall Conference| Community Foundations| Economy

16 Sep 2010

Newsweek Senior Editor Daniel Gross dug into his fried chicken and mashed potatoes like a man facing a rapidly approaching deadline. His plenary session presentation at the Council on Foundations 2010 fall conference was only minutes away.

Steve Gunderson briefed him on the audience with practiced ease. Mr. Gross nodded like a quarterback getting sideline instructions. He had given this talk before, but this was his first time addressing leaders of the nonprofit sector. His audiences usually are Fortune 500 companies eager for an outsider’s perspective.

I leaned across the table and mentioned an emerging trend I am seeing in Charleston, South Carolina: the rise of entrepreneurial donors. He brushed the comment aside with a friendly nod and a “you’ll see.” He made his way to the podium.

Mr. Gross quickly got to the point of his presentation. The “gathering of the glum,” (meaning the economic punditocracy) has gotten the economic recovery all wrong. We are making more progress, faster, in our economic recovery than most acknowledge. We are becoming more efficient and faster than ever before, squeezing a remarkable six percent increase in efficiency out of our economy in the past 12 months.

Why do so many get it wrong? Economic forecasting is based on looking backward and projecting forward. The tools economists use are all based on the recent past as a starting point. There is something like “muscle memory” in economic forecasts. If you are used to cringing, then you cringe. This causes economists to miss the inflection points—the moments when the markets turn. Mr. Gross has seen the economies of the world turn by looking at the recent successes of several U.S. companies, but in particular Apple and Google.

Our greatest companies create platforms that become new economic ecosystems. Apple, Google, Boeing, GM (even in bankruptcy), and others are creating new economic ecosystems on which the fastest growing new business sectors around the world are based. The entrepreneurs behind these companies are U.S.-based, yet their ideas drive the global economy. We are the platform for global growth and the world is taking us along with them…not leaving us behind.

After Mr. Gross ended his talk and the applause died down I thought, community foundations are a platform for the nonprofit ecosystem. Do we encourage donor innovation using our platform? Do we engage the entrepreneurial donors in our communities? To fail to do so is to be left behind in the recovery of the nonprofit sector.

George Stevens is president and CEO of the Coastal Community Foundation of South Carolina

Comment Form

Welcome to RE: Philanthropy! In this blog, guest and Council bloggers share ideas and insights on the most pressing issues in philanthropy. If you want to contribute, please contact

The opinions expressed in this blog are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the Council on Foundations.


Neville Vakharia
Daniel Jae-Won Lee
Kim Embretson and Tom McSparron
Kisha Green Dimbo
Carl Little
Stanley S. Litow
Ashley Blanchard
Valerie S. Lies
Jeff Yost
Vikki Porter
Roger Doughty
Carmen Fields
Elizabeth Ramirez
Joop Rubens
Mena Amin
Sophia Guevara
Noel McLaughlin
Mark Baldassare
Danielle Williams
Sheri Booms Holm
Mike Sweeney
Darryl Lester
Dr. Peter Long
Rockhelle Johnson
Steve Gunderson
Sean Stannard-Stockton
Latonya Slack
Deidre Lind
Susan Price
Michael Moody
Debra Jacobs
John F. Rohe
Allison Sole
Chatrane Birbal
Chris Cardona
Jennifer Lentfer
David Maurrasse
Audrey Jacobs
Nancy Van Milligen
Anne Vally
Heather Peeler
George Stevens
Emmett Carson
John Tyler
Katie Loovis
Kevin Salwen
Michelle Bermudez
Juanita T James
James Head
Erica Wood