David EtzwilerCorporate Philanthropy and Citizenship Leaders Need a New Script

By: David Etzwiler In: Corporate Philanthropy

14 Jun 2011

Earlier this month, a group of corporate citizenship leaders representing a range of industries assembled in New York to answer this question: What must we do to transform the corporate philanthropy and corporate citizenship fields?

The context of the question comes at a time when business’ role in society has been fundamentally altered. Globalization and the declining capacity of governments means the private sector is increasingly being asked-and sometimes required-to solve seemingly intractable global challenges in health, environment, education, and poverty alleviation. At the same time, leading corporations and their stakeholders are increasingly convinced that integrated business and social strategies are not only compatible, but good and necessary for their future prosperity.

Corporate citizenship and corporate philanthropy have leading roles to play in catalyzing business to create social and financial value. But, a mindset and role shift is required to move the field forward and realize the promise of the approach.

While corporate philanthropy-sometimes described as the “headlights” of corporate social responsibly-is eager to claim its full potential and contribute its unique value to society, significant barriers encumber the field. Internally, philanthropy and corporate citizenship functions are too often disconnected and marginalized from core business strategies. Externally, a lack of standardization means the collective impact and potential of the full range of corporate assets-beyond just the dollars-is too easily and too quickly overlooked. As a result, recognition of the true potential of philanthropy and corporate citizenship is fundamentally challenged by the story of who we are, what we do, and why we do it. We need a new narrative.

To help the field address these urgent issues and re-imagine the future, the Council on Foundations recently launched an exciting initiative masked by a pedestrian name, “Corporate Philanthropy 2012.” Sponsored and led by leading global companies, the project’s aim is to inspire a paradigm shift to reorient corporate philanthropy and corporate citizenship and equip the field with a practical roadmap on how to get there. The June 3 workshop in New York was part of an ongoing dialogue with corporate leaders that included six regional meetings earlier this year.

I know this transformational journey is one that the corporate field must take if we’re serious about maximizing our value and impact in society. I encourage you to follow along with us by weighing in through this blog post and others to come.

David Etzwiler is a Council board member, chair of the Global Philanthropy Committee, and immediate past chair of the Corporate Committee. He was most recently the vice president of Community Affairs and executive director of the Medtronic Foundation. Etzwiler co-chairs the Corporate Philanthropy 2012 Task Force with Ann Cramer of IBM. 

7 Responses to Corporate Philanthropy and Citizenship Leaders Need a New Script

Laura McKnight

June 15th, 2011 at 8:46 am

Wonderful initiative! Good for you for taking it on.

Melissa Pailthorp

June 15th, 2011 at 11:50 pm

Indeed, a worthwhile conversation and above is a great set up. My hope is that what will evolve will be deeper than the ‘for’ or ‘against’ dichotomy that seems to swirl around CSR and instead really dig into how a company might rise to the challenge, but not let philanthropy become just another strain of marketing. Is such commitment possible? If necessary ‘because of the declining capacity of some governments’ then what parameters should guide the field? Are corporate foundations the answer or are they by definition too distant from core business strategy?

I look forward to more (and a link to summary of 6 preceeding regional meetings?)

Thanks for your efforts!

Sylvie Laffarge

June 16th, 2011 at 10:06 am

Happy to read about this. It is such an ongoing issue and one all of us Corporate philanthropy colleagues have to tackle. CSR is definitely in transition. I look forward to this exchange and hope we can contribute.

Michael Bzdak

June 17th, 2011 at 8:34 am

I appreciate COF’s leadership on this important issue. The heart of the question is gaining an understanding, from various stakeholders, as to what is the role of business in society. Secondly, we should all be calling for a marriage of numbers and stories. Don’t underestimate the power of quantitative data coupled with compellling human narratives. We will discover that there are many ways that companies create value.

Marsha Shotley

August 19th, 2011 at 8:52 am

I look forward to learning more and participating in the Corporate Philanthropy 2012 work. As a corporate foundation we look to the national council to help us think through and recommend goals and strategies that can take our programs to the next level. This initiative will help us all in these fast-paced times through value creation.

Corporate Philanthropy 2012: The Conversation Is Just Beginning - RE:Philanthropy

October 11th, 2011 at 1:03 pm

[...] social and environmental challenges we all face. In addition, the Corporate Committee has been discussing the changing role of philanthropy as part of Corporate Philanthropy 2012. Here are some of the [...]


November 1st, 2011 at 9:50 am

His accomplishments were unmatched. People who can claim credit for game-changing products — iconic inventions that become embedded in the culture and answers to Jeopardy questions decades later — are few and far between. But Jobs has had not one, not two, but six of these breakthroughs, any one of which would have made for a magnificent career. In order: the Apple II, the Macintosh, the movie studio Pixar, the iPod, the iPhone and the iPad. (This doesn’t even include the consistent, brilliant improvements to the Macintosh operating system, or the Apple retail store juggernaut.) Had he lived a natural lifespan, there would have almost certainly been more.
Behind any human being is a mystery: What happened to make him … him? When considering extraordinary people, the question becomes an obsession. What produces the sort of people who create world-changing products, inspire by example and shock by justified audacity, and tag billions of minds with memetic graffiti? What led to his dead-on product sense, his haughty confidence, his ability to simultaneously hector and inspire people to do their best work?

Comment Form

Welcome to RE: Philanthropy! In this blog, guest and Council bloggers share ideas and insights on the most pressing issues in philanthropy. If you want to contribute, please contact webteam@cof.org.

The opinions expressed in this blog are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the Council on Foundations.


Stephanie Powers
PJ Watters
Amanda St. Pierre
Ann Cramer
Aleesha Towns-Bain
David P. Janes
Claudia Juech
Susan Meier
Brad Phillips
Jennifer Ford Reedy
Aimee Guidera
Allison Sole
Trista Harris
Sam Davis
Vartan Gregorian
Sterling Speirn
Larry Ottinger
Kathryn Merchant
Kaberi Banerjee-Murthy
Caroline Roan and Atiya Weiss
Brenda Chumley
Daniel Jae-Won Lee
Diana Doyle
Daniel Mansoor
Lois Salisbury
Anne Sekula
John Padilla
David Imbert
David Abramson
Chet Hewitt
Emmett Carson
Lisa Philp
Hallie Preskill Mayur Patel and Charles Gasper
Rotary International
Mafruza Khan
Mayur Patel
Paul Connolly
Lynn Broaddus
Daria Teutonico
Candace Winkler
Jeff Stanger
Nancy Henry
Susan Misra
Jacob Gayle
Debra Jacobs
Matt Robertson
Nicole Lewis
Daniel Kaufman
Ruby Takanishi
Denise Spencer