Rajasvini BhansaliInvesting in Local Solutions to Global Challenges

By: Rajasvini Bhansali In: Global Philanthropy| Philanthropy| Poverty| Rural Philanthropy

30 Mar 2012

A few years ago, a Guatemalan organization called the Women’s Association for the Development of Sacatepéquez (AFEDES), an International Development Exchange (IDEX) grant partner since 2005, discovered something troubling: Its programs were not making much of an impact.

Comprised of 31 women’s groups in Guatemala with nearly 1,000 members, AFEDES was founded by a group of indigenous women seeking to improve their economic opportunities through microcredit, financial management, income-generating skills building, and more. AFEDES began to see that some women were deeper in debt than at the start of the economic program. Women were not participating as actively outside their homes as AFEDES had hoped. Inside their homes, nutrition levels were not improving.

Although micro-credit at the time was seen by many in the aid community as a magic bullet to eradicate poverty, the women of AFEDES looked deeper and came to an important conclusion: Women’s oppression could not be solved by credit alone. The organization started a new, 18-week program to empower indigenous women by educating and informing them about the legal and social mechanisms that exist to protect them from injustice. Today, AFEDES is training women to become community organizers and advocating for a rural women’s shelter specifically for indigenous women in the region, a policy victory they intend to realize this year.

“When we started our work,” Amarillis Guamuch, AFEDES’ fearless leader, told me upon my recent visit to Guatemala, “we knew it would change families, communities and our country for good. We knew that patriarchy would be challenged; so would the church and the economic system. We knew that, together, women would recuperate not only the soil and seeds on our land, but in fact, the soul of our society.”

Yet, the story of AFEDES is not just the story of what can happen when we invest in women. It is also about what can happen when we invest in the local leaders and organizations in our world’s most marginalized communities. Like AFEDES, these leaders have the best understanding of the culture, history, and conditions of their own communities, and are in the best positions to address the root causes of poverty, injustice, and inequality.

The problem is that this is not the way most international philanthropy is currently practiced. Instead, large-scale development efforts are initiated and led by people and organizations external to the communities directly impacted by poverty and injustice. These efforts fail to take into account the knowledge and experience that already exists in these communities, and don’t have a deep understanding of the efforts that will be most effective in the long run. The results are often limited and short-lived, and groups on the frontlines, like AFEDES, don’t get access to the funding they so desperately need to thrive and grow.

At IDEX, we believe that we still have much work to do to turn this largely broken model of philanthropy on its head. We pioneered and continue to champion a partnership-based grantmaking model in Africa, Asia, and Latin America that powers social change from the ground up. We provide flexible, long-term grants directly to grassroots groups that have the trust of their neighbors and the knowledge of what is needed in their own communities.

Recently, we commissioned an evaluation report because we wanted to hear directly from our partners as to whether our model works. According to the findings, nearly 100 percent of our grant partners found our model effective and nearly 90 percent stated they have been able to develop local, community-based solutions.

My visit with groups like AFEDES in Guatemala left me humbled by the courage of these community leaders to move forward in their quests for justice despite tremendous obstacles and to work toward dismantling systems of oppression for good. It left me more convinced than ever that we must put power back in the hands of marginalized communities by supporting local solutions, honoring grassroots leadership, and relying on local knowledge. When matched with the vision, resolve, and ingenuity of communities all over the world, this model is a proven formula for lasting change.

Rajasvini Bhansali is executive director of San Francisco-based International Development Exchange.

5 Responses to Investing in Local Solutions to Global Challenges

Carrie

April 2nd, 2012 at 2:34 pm

Thank you for sharing IDEX’s commitment to supporting local solutions. It was inspiring to hear to hear Amarillis Guamuch words about AFEDES’ dedication to change!

Jonathan Lewis

April 4th, 2012 at 2:25 am

Certainly agree that micro-finance must be married to other social services, such as health, education and empowerment. Poverty is a plague of many pathologies, so it requires a “solution cocktail.” (To the reader: Ms. Bhansali’s Video Collection will soon be available at http://www.iOnPoverty.tv.)

Kiki Mills Johnston

April 11th, 2012 at 6:49 pm

It’s the age old rule in marketing & advertising - LISTEN to your customers and they will tell you what you need to know. Only your customers know the real needs, challenges, thoughts, solutions and ideas to make something work. That’s what IDEX helps to facilitate, in a much more meaningful way than my more capitalistic example. But the principle remains the same - LISTEN. And as the age old logic goes - never ASSUME - or you will make an ass out of you and me.

Diane

April 25th, 2012 at 3:53 pm

Micro-finances without the social context of Women’s Rights misses the opportunity for lasting change in wealth distribution. And financial projects without consideration of the environment is not sustainable. Development is always within a context, whether we recognize it our not. IDEX is obviously paying attention, and is right-on target by linking the issues of women’s empowerment, building local economies, and sustainable development.

Diane Dodge, Executive Director, East Bay College Fund and fan of IDEX!

Ken Wilson

April 28th, 2012 at 10:58 am

Yes a powerful example of what happens when you back people with the courage and wisdom to actually press for a locally crafted solution, rather than extend them whatever is the fashionable package this year among aid circles. Hats off to IDEX for having the honesty to recognize what wasn’t working and for responding with a long term partnership of such inspiring women.

Comment Form


Welcome to RE: Philanthropy! In this blog, guest and Council bloggers share ideas and insights on the most pressing issues in philanthropy. If you want to contribute, please contact webteam@cof.org.

The opinions expressed in this blog are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the Council on Foundations.

Contributors

Stuart Comstock-Gay
Regan Gruber Moffitt
Mark Hecker
Steve Delfin
Mayur Patel
Brittany Jenkins
Matt Robertson
Jim Mayfield
Ira Strumwasser, Ph.D.
Rockhelle Johnson
Larry Ottinger
Kari Dunn Saratovsky
David Maurrasse
Richard Ober
Robert Smith
Michelle Bermudez
Jennifer Lentfer
Kristin Ivie
Mary Vallier-Kaplan
Deborah Hoover
Melissa Bradley
Brenda Campers
Collis Townsend
Rachel Leon
Heidi Sytsema
Nathan Dungan
Dinah Waldsmith Dittman
Regine A. Webster
Sean Stannard-Stockton
David Biemesderfer
Claudia Juech
Jeff Stanger
Kari Jackson
Anne Sekula
Akhtar Badshah
Erin Rowley
Rajasvini Bhansali
Daniel Kaufman
Clotilde DeDecker
Neville Vakharia
Susan McPherson
Anita Scism
Daniela Fainberg
Paul Major
Evelyn Gibson
Courtney Spalding-Mayer
Paul Connolly
Linda Reed
Laura Tomasko
Frank Alvarez