NicoleMobilizing Separate, but Equally — or can we Choose to Create a More Perfect Union?

By: Nicole Robinson In: 2012 Annual Conference| Diversity and Inclusion| Global Philanthropy

30 Apr 2012

Saturday was wonderful preconference kick-off to what will undoubtedly be another great Council on Foundations event. Collaboration, common agendas, and community engagement were key themes for both the Association of Black Foundation Executives (ABFE) and Global Grantmakers. Each group delivered thought-provoking, inspiring programming - but unfortunately I was forced to choose between sessions.  Similar to previous conferences, I was forced to make the mad dash between presentations and sneak politely in and out of conversations that were great independently but have the potential to be transformative together. I don’t know about you, but I’m ready to mobilize to create a more perfect Council union.

Highlights from the ABFE schedule included a session highlighting a successful multisector, multigenerational collaborative by the African American Leadership Forum. It convened leaders from philanthropy, business, and government to champion a common African-American agenda across five states. The usual social issues were the focus:  education, economic justice, and health disparities. Additionally, the collaborative has been successful at diversifying the leaders to include not just African Americans but immigrants from Africa and the Caribbean.

The day culminated with the James Joseph Lecturer, Karen Kelley-Ariwoola, who challenged us to contemplate our community legacy and vision. The legacy of her work at the Minneapolis Foundation is what Emmett Carson described as “tombstone grants” - those worthy enough to be on one’s tombstone. The audience was full of ABFE members listening intently, but quite frankly it was a worthy topic for many grantmakers,  not exclusively African Americans.  

So why weren’t others in the in the room? Might the session and the programs benefitted from greater diversity?

Simultaneously, Global Grantmakers widened their philanthropic lens to discuss the human development of people of color around the globe. Participants explored the role African women play in society and culture. Their evening culminated with a presentation by actress Julia Ormond on her work with the Alliance to Stop Slavery and End Trafficking. Ormond’s presentation was indeed eye-opening social justice work that is critical to the growth of black and brown people around the world. Yet noticeably absent were quite a few black and brown participants. So again I say, why weren’t others in the room? Might the session and programs have benefitted from greater diversity?

To quote Barack Obama, “We hold common hopes. We may not look the same, and we may not have come from the same place, but we all want to move in the same direction — toward a better future. We perfect our union by recognizing our different stories.”

Reflecting on my mad dash between sessions, I was reminded of what is imperfect about our union, the Council on Foundations. As philanthropists, we should shamelessly steal from Barack Obama’s playbook by creating a more perfect union - right in our backyard. And as a part of our responsibility, I challenge individual conference attendees to break out of your silos and join unique conversations, understand a new demographic, and find a convergence between these ideas and your daily work.  

And I challenge next year’s conference planning team to build a bridge between affinity groups like ABFE and Global Grantmakers. Perhaps the 2013 James Joseph Lecturer can be a recipient who has championed philanthropy across Africa and the Caribbean? Might the lecture and reception be a joint event between ABFE and Global Grantmakers? How can we create a more perfect union between the two groups? And I welcome your ideas, as next year I desperately hope to abandon the mad dash between sessions.

Nicole Robinson is vice president of the Krafts Food Foundation.

1 Response to Mobilizing Separate, but Equally — or can we Choose to Create a More Perfect Union?

Celene Peurye

May 1st, 2012 at 1:32 am

I understand and share your feelings Nicole. I think that this has been a long-time concern of the various affinity groups. There has always been wonderful rich content that many have thought should be available to everyone at the larger conference. Over the years I’ve observed CoF incorporating more of this content and the suggestions of the affinity groups into the regular conference. But undoubtedly there are time constraints and also other reasons why the affinity groups may feel they are better served to maintaining some of the content in their own offerings.
But I have also wondered over the years if some of the meetings of the affinity groups are open for anyone to attend or only their consituencies or membership? Often, information about these pre, during or post - conference sessions is not widely available outside of their membership. To make this information available and offer an open invitation may help to de-silo and get this exciting and important work out to more people.

Comment Form

Welcome to RE: Philanthropy! In this blog, guest and Council bloggers share ideas and insights on the most pressing issues in philanthropy. If you want to contribute, please contact

The opinions expressed in this blog are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the Council on Foundations.


Barnett Baron
Vikki Spruill
Monica Buhlig
Clotilde DeDecker
Phil Buchanan
Michelle Bermudez
Ron Ancrum
Ray Knott
Michael Smith
Lori Bertman
Dr. Peter Long
Katherine Lorenz
Ali Webb
Ben Francisco Maulbeck
Candace Winkler
Chris Pinney
Tina Arnoldi
Kate Ahern
Karen Archer Perry and Chauncy Lennon
Robert K. Ross
Dori Kreiger
Mena Amin
Terence Mulligan
Evelyn Gibson
Rita L. Soronen
Peter Brach
Elaine Gast Fawcett
Josephine Sinclair
Jeff Pickering and Susanne Norgard
Adrienne Vargas
Malika Harrison
Lisa Parker
Lynn Broaddus
Craig Muska
Albert Ruesga
Kelly Shipp Simone
Daniela Fainberg
Daniel Olias Silverman
Frank Alvarez
Timothy P. Silard
Jorgen Thomsen
Laura Meyer
Judy Sjostedt
Michelle Kalina
Michael L. Batchelor
Ruby Takanishi
Audrey Jacobs
Deborah Hoover
Mimi Box, Mimi Corcoran Jane Vincent, and Stewart Sarkozy-Banoczy