Michael BzdakIn Praise of Extraordinary Measures

By: Michael Bzdak In: 2013 Annual Conference| Philanthropy

1 Feb 2013

Who can argue with Bill Gates and his call for a more thoughtful and holistic approach to measurement?

It sounds like a simple equation: If you want to achieve progress, you set a clear goal and find a measure, or measures, that will drive progress toward that goal.

Ideally, however, measurement is a way of thinking. It answers the question, “What does success look like?” and should be part of daily practice and a key to any funder/grantee conversation. Many program officers are already conversant in logic modeling, theories of change, and goal setting. In addition, resources are increasingly being devoted to collecting, analyzing, and communicating/visualizing data; reporting the results; and using those results to improve and promote programs.

Implicit in Gates’ essay is the fact that funders and grantees require the capacity and proficiency to set clear goals and design the means to measure progress. This shared responsibility creates an opportunity for meaningful dialogue and collaboration and could deliver the innovations in measurement that Gates suggests. Although measurement can be very complex and difficult, grantmakers have a responsibility to make it one of their core competencies.

With a robust strategic giving plan, the contributions team at Johnson & Johnson is continuing on a journey to improve our ability, and that of our partners, to measure and communicate program results. We are certainly interested in the quantitative (numbers) and the qualitative (stories) results of our partnerships around the world. We have embraced “evaluation thinking” within the context of a global corporate giving program and created a “tiger team,” a cross-discipline sub-team which works to continuously improve our team’s ability to measure outcomes while improving our partners’ evaluation capacity. Embracing evaluation thinking has improved our practice on many levels, especially our relationships with community partners.

Among funders, more dialogue around measurement will surely improve the quality of our work. Program outcomes and results are directly linked to how we, as funders, demonstrate the impact and value of our work to our stakeholders. As Chris Pinney concluded in Increasing Impact, Enhancing Value: A Practitioner’s Guide to Leading Corporate Philanthropy: “In this time of turbulence and change, all organizations are being asked to rethink their purpose and actions to create greater value for society. We believe an enormous opportunity exists today for leaders in corporate philanthropy to step up to this challenge.”

Come join the conversation around value at the Council on Foundations Annual Conference in Chicago.

Michael Bzdak, Ph.D., is a director of corporate contributions for Johnson & Johnson and serves on the Council’s Corporate Committee.

1 Response to In Praise of Extraordinary Measures

Nicole R. Robinson

February 5th, 2013 at 5:15 pm

Great, thought-provoking comments Michael. And we too are on a measurement journey at Mondelez International and hope to get better in raging increments. We want to achieve better outcomes, but like many of our corporate grantmaking peers face the obstacles of limited time, money and resources. To help move us forward, we will convene severall of our grantees together in hopes of agreeing on a global set of metrics. We’re hoping this collaborative approach will be a step in the right direction. Although, I must admit — I’m envious of your “tiger team” tasked with demonstrating impact and look forward to learning more at the annual conference.

Comment Form


Welcome to RE: Philanthropy! In this blog, guest and Council bloggers share ideas and insights on the most pressing issues in philanthropy. If you want to contribute, please contact webteam@cof.org.

The opinions expressed in this blog are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the Council on Foundations.

Contributors

Margaret Gage
Mimi Box, Mimi Corcoran Jane Vincent, and Stewart Sarkozy-Banoczy
Sandie Palomo-Gonzalez
Amy Philips Haller
Kate Ahern
Andres Spokoiny
Danielle Williams
Linda Reed
PJ Watters
Jessica del Rosario
Jeff Pryor
Neville Vakharia
Laurel Lee-Alexander
Sara Watson
Helen Brunner
Jim Mayfield
John Kobara
Ira Strumwasser Ph.D. and Beverly Church
Regan Gruber Moffitt
Van Evans
Jessica Janssen
David P. Janes
Julia Boyer and Danny Murphy
Ellen Carter
Noel McLaughlin
Richard Sussman
Jenny Chan
Roger Doughty
John Padilla
Larry Kutner
John Stremsterfer
Ronn Richard
Albert Ruesga
Sherry Ristau
Karen Archer Perry and Chauncy Lennon
Liza Petra
Paulette V. Maehara
Kari Jackson
Nichole Baker
Lorrie Fair
John Anderson
Kathryn Merchant
Stanley S. Litow
Steve Gunderson
Ali Webb
THNKR
Nancy Jost
BH Kim
Frank Alvarez
David Wood